TV Series
The Girl on the Milk Carton
Five days before Christmas 1984, 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews vanished from her home in Greeley, Colorado. Her face was among the first to appear on milk cartons in an attempt to find her, but the publicity did not lead to her return.
More To Explore
Need something different after this episode?
These matched outbound cards give The Girl on the Milk Carton viewers a smooth next-click path into browser games, short-drama discovery, and downloader tools while preserving the same premium dark-glass presentation.
Gamixo
Switch from series time to quick browser games with a vibrant, instantly playable lineup that still fits the same entertainment-first mood.
VSKIT Drama
Keep the late-night scroll going with bold short-drama artwork and another snackable entertainment stop built for fast discovery.
OmniSave
Save videos, clips, and trailers with a streamlined downloader destination that complements the binge-and-share habits of streaming users.
Trailer
Cast
Marcus Plowright
Director
Jonelle Matthews
Self - Murder Victim
Jonelle Matthews
Self - Story Subject
Christian Dalton
Self - Patrol Officer Mark Blaszkiewicz
Mike Prill
Self - Detective at Greeley Colorado Police Dept.
Steve Pankey
Self - Convicted of the 1984 Murder of Jonelle Matthews
Jennifer Mogensen
Self - Sister of Jonelle Matthews
Eileen Huff
Self - Matthews Family Friend
Eileen Huff
Self - Spearheaded the 'Rescue Jonelle' Search & Charity Efforts
Angela Hicks
Self - Former wife of Steve Pankey
Gloria Matthews
Self - Mother of Jonelle Matthews
Deanna Ross
Self - Best Friend of Jonelle Matthews
Russell Ross
Self - Father of Deanna Ross
Russell Ross
Self - Matthews' Family Friend
Mark Blasziewicz
Self - Patrol Officer at Greeley Colorado Police Dept.
Jim Matthews
Self - Father of Jonelle Matthews
Ronald Reagan
Self - Former U.S. President
Edward Dentzel
Self - True Crime and Missing Persons Podcaster
Jim Christy
Self - Former Matthews Family Pastor in Greeley Colorado
Michael Rourke
Self - Weld County District Attorney
Lacy Wells
Self - Weld County Deputy District Attorney
Robert Cash
Self - Detective at Greeley Colorado Police Dept.
You Might Also Like
The Girl on the Milk Carton
2024 · Documentary / Crime
Dirty Money
2018 · Documentary / Crime
The Keepers
2017 · Documentary / Crime
History's Greatest Heists
2023 · Documentary / Crime
Snapped: Killer Couples
2013 · Documentary / Crime
Perfect Wife: The Mysterious Disappearance of Sherri Papini
2024 · Documentary / Crime
911: Did the Killer Call?
2025 · Documentary / Crime
The Line
2021 · Documentary / Crime
Deadly Influence: The Social Media Murders
2024 · Documentary / Crime
Taken Together: Who Killed Lyric and Elizabeth?
2024 · Documentary / Crime
The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre
2023 · Documentary / Crime
Wicked Game: Devil in the Desert
2025 · Documentary / Crime
Comments
6 Comments